Wertkritik (German: [ˈveːɐ̯tkʁiˌtiːk]; lit. "value critique") is a school of Marxian critical theory that emerged in Germany in the 1980s. It sees itself as a continuation of Karl Marx's "esoteric" critique of the value-form, which it argues has been largely abandoned or misunderstood by "traditional" or "workers'-movement Marxism". The school's central figures include Robert Kurz, Roswitha Scholz, Norbert Trenkle, and Ernst Lohoff. Its main theoretical organs have been the journals Krisis and, following a 2004 split, Exit!. The core of Wertkritik is a fundamental critique of the basic categories of capitalist society—value, commodity, money, and abstract labour—which it understands not as neutral economic concepts but as historically specific forms of social mediation that constitute a "real abstraction" governing social life. Unlike traditional Marxist analyses that focus on class struggle over the distribution of surplus value, Wertkritik identifies the value form itself as the object of critique. It argues that labour in capitalism is not a transhistorical source of wealth but a historically specific, "oppressive, inhumane, and antisocial activity" whose sole purpose is the endless accumulation of abstract wealth (value). Wertkritik is primarily a theory of crisis, positing that capitalism possesses an absolute internal limit. It argues that the system's relentless drive to increase productivity through technology progressively expels living labour—the sole source of value—from production. This creates a fundamental contradiction: while material wealth increases, the production of value diminishes, ultimately leading to a "terminal crisis" of the capitalist mode of production. A major development within the school is Roswitha Scholz's theory of "value-dissociation" (Wertabspaltung), which posits that the value form necessarily dissociates and devalues activities, affects, and qualities coded as feminine, making this gendered dissociation a precondition of capitalist society. Wertkritik has had a significant reception in Brazil but remains largely unknown in the Anglophone world.
History
Wertkritik emerged from the West German radical left of the 1970s and 1980s. In 1986, a group based primarily in Nuremberg, whose members came from diverse revolutionary Marxist backgrounds including ex-members of the K-Gruppen and the autonomist scene, founded the journal Marxistische Kritik (Marxist Critique). The first issue contained Robert Kurz's essay "The Crisis of Exchange Value" (Die Krise des Tauschwerts), which has been described as "the founding document of value-critique". This essay laid out the core argument that capitalism's drive to increase productivity through technology leads to the expulsion of value-creating labour, thus creating an insurmountable internal contradiction. Following the fall of the Berlin Wall, the journal was renamed Krisis in 1990. The group engaged with and distanced itself from other currents of Marxist thought, including Western Marxism (particularly the Frankfurt School and György Lukács), the German Neue Marx-Lektüre, and the "anti-German" communist tendency that arose from similar political milieus. While sometimes grouped with the Neue Marx-Lektüre, Wertkritik is distinguished by its origins in a more extra-academic radical milieu, a more vocal opposition to traditional Marxist politics, and a greater focus on the forms of subjectivity that capitalism engenders. Throughout the 1990s, the school developed its core concepts, with Kurz emerging as its most prominent and prolific theorist, notably with the 1999 publication of his magnum opus, Schwarzbuch Kapitalismus (The Black Book of Capitalism).
In 2004, the Krisis group experienced a "conflict-ridden and at times highly polemical public split". As a result, Kurz, Roswitha Scholz, and other members left to form the new journal Exit!. The remaining Krisis group continued under the editorship of Norbert Trenkle and Ernst Lohoff. The Exit! group has since tended to describe its approach as Wertabspaltungskritik (critique of value-dissociation) to highlight the centrality of Scholz's theory to its framework. Another associated publication, the Vienna-based Streifzüge, is loosely allied with the Krisis group.
Core tenets
Critique of traditional Marxism and labour Wertkritik defines itself in opposition to what it calls "traditional Marxism" or "workers'-movement Marxism". It argues that most Marxist traditions have failed to grasp the radicality of Karl Marx's "esoteric" critique of the value-form, settling instead for an "exoteric" critique focused on class struggle over the distribution of wealth. This traditional view, according to Wertkritik, remains trapped within the categories of capitalist society by affirming labour as a transhistorical, positive point of departure for critique. From this perspective, exploitation is seen as an injustice where surplus value is unfairly appropriated by capitalists, and the socialist project becomes one of liberating labour and ensuring a just distribution of its products. In stark contrast, Wertkritik insists that labour itself is a category to be critiqued. Drawing on Marx's early writings, it views labour in capitalism not as a universal condition of human existence but as a historically specific "oppressive, inhumane, and antisocial activity that both is determined by and produces private property". It argues that "labour" as a separate sphere of life, governed by abstract time and aimed solely at the valorization of value, is the fundamental problem, not the standpoint of its solution. The goal is therefore not the liberation of labour, but liberation from labour.
… excerpt ends here. Continue reading the full article.
